We are all heartbroken, can’t stop crying. Somehow there was such hope… I really believed that Hersh, in the spotlight of his parents’ love and advocacy, would be spared. That his mother would hug him again, that his life would resume, different and halting, certainly, but continue.
And Eden. Ori. Alex. Carmel. Almog. I find myself searching them out online, poring over the details of their lives, fingers tracing the outlines of their faces in photos. I want to feel as though I know them, the way I feel like I know Hersh. The way I know Naama Levy, with her bloody, sagging pajama pants, the way I knew Noa Argamani, long hair flying as she cries on a motorcycle, arm outstretched to her boyfriend.
May their memories be a revolution. May justice prevail, may goodness and sweetness ultimately emerge from this nightmare.
What a heartfelt sharing. Thank you, Emily. Brings tears.We said the names of the Hostages as we went around at the Passover Seder...as many families did. I am certain in the heavens they be compensated.
Thank you for bearing witness with your agonizingly truthful account of our pain at the loss of our hostages, the suffering of our people and the continuing suffering that Jews all around the world have experienced since that horrible black Saturday of October 7th. I’m a writer (poetry and essays) and am grateful to have found your blog. One of my poems about October 7th and its aftermath is a tribute to our people and particularly our hostages who are still suffering in Gaza. It references the five female surveillance soldiers who were so brutally ripped from their base on that terrible morning and are still in the horrific tunnels of Gaza. My poem also references Hersh Goldberg-Polin (may his memory forever be a blessing) and it was published on 22 August 2024. I’m sharing it here in the hopes that it will be a small tribute and evidence of my shattered heart just as so many others have been shattered by this continuing nightmare.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts from Tel Aviv and your raw emotions. I am from Chicago vacationing in NYC. We were devastated last night when we heard the news, as the Goldberg-Polin family have strong connections to Chicago. The Jewish community in Chicago is heartbroken too. ❤️
So beautifully stated. We are all so heartbroken over the news today but continue to be hopeful that perhaps other hostages come home. It the only way to push forward. Thank you for your words Adeena.
Thank you for putting all the mess of emotions into words, Adeena. I love you.
The sentiments of us all, so beautifully written...
Thank you, Adeena.
I am devastated and so angry!
We are all heartbroken, can’t stop crying. Somehow there was such hope… I really believed that Hersh, in the spotlight of his parents’ love and advocacy, would be spared. That his mother would hug him again, that his life would resume, different and halting, certainly, but continue.
And Eden. Ori. Alex. Carmel. Almog. I find myself searching them out online, poring over the details of their lives, fingers tracing the outlines of their faces in photos. I want to feel as though I know them, the way I feel like I know Hersh. The way I know Naama Levy, with her bloody, sagging pajama pants, the way I knew Noa Argamani, long hair flying as she cries on a motorcycle, arm outstretched to her boyfriend.
May their memories be a revolution. May justice prevail, may goodness and sweetness ultimately emerge from this nightmare.
Thank you for your beautiful tribute 🙏
What a heartfelt sharing. Thank you, Emily. Brings tears.We said the names of the Hostages as we went around at the Passover Seder...as many families did. I am certain in the heavens they be compensated.
Everything you said. I appreciate all that you have articulated. Like sand slipping through our fingers…💔
Thank you for bearing witness with your agonizingly truthful account of our pain at the loss of our hostages, the suffering of our people and the continuing suffering that Jews all around the world have experienced since that horrible black Saturday of October 7th. I’m a writer (poetry and essays) and am grateful to have found your blog. One of my poems about October 7th and its aftermath is a tribute to our people and particularly our hostages who are still suffering in Gaza. It references the five female surveillance soldiers who were so brutally ripped from their base on that terrible morning and are still in the horrific tunnels of Gaza. My poem also references Hersh Goldberg-Polin (may his memory forever be a blessing) and it was published on 22 August 2024. I’m sharing it here in the hopes that it will be a small tribute and evidence of my shattered heart just as so many others have been shattered by this continuing nightmare.
https://ironwordsisrael.com/say-their-names/
Thank you. משתתפים בצער גם מפה.
Thank you, Rabbi Malomet!
Thank you for sharing your thoughts from Tel Aviv and your raw emotions. I am from Chicago vacationing in NYC. We were devastated last night when we heard the news, as the Goldberg-Polin family have strong connections to Chicago. The Jewish community in Chicago is heartbroken too. ❤️
So utterly heartbreaking 💔. Beautifully written.
So beautifully stated. We are all so heartbroken over the news today but continue to be hopeful that perhaps other hostages come home. It the only way to push forward. Thank you for your words Adeena.
Brought tears. And so well-written.
Thank you Adeena 🩷
Just remember where the evil is. Hamas. Who stole Hersh. Who murdered Hersh. Who stole and murdered many more.
Who ever said otherwise.
weeping
So beautifully said, painful as this all is. Thank you❤️